This cake was *fantastic*!! What I tried, because there are just 2 of us, is to halve this wonderful recipe. Martha Stewart may receive compensation when you click through and purchase from links contained on The topping is also super dense (with all that butter) and had a 50/50 ratio of cake to topping. Which leads to some pretty amazing crumble action. I adopted this recipe from the Recipezaar account. The canola oil made it dense and the overall taste was weird. Bake in a 325 degree oven for 20 minutes or until a toothpick comes out clean. I also stuffed my face with the last two slices of this New York Style Crumb Cake. Crumb cake is best when very fresh. After all, you are in search of a dessert that is freshly baked and made with top-notch ingredients. Way too dense and didn't really cook through. I've been making it for years--and lost the recipe...so glad to have stumbled across it again! This recipe is called Shortcut New York Crumb Cake because I used a boxed cake mix for the cake. https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/new-york-style-crumb-cake The recipe was easy, the cake delicious. cinnamon. It tastes so much better than the brand name version you can buy at the store. Set aside. Madison and I went to the Cake Boss bakery in Hoboken, NJ a few years back. I also didn't have any canola oil so I substituted vegetable oil, which was fine. It's like baking a crumb-topped coffee cake on top of another coffee cake! Want more tasty and festive holiday cookie recipes and tips? I grew up in Nutley, as did Martha, and we may have gotten our crumb cake at the same bakery. Thanks again Martha for another fabulous recipe. That might actually solve this. Cool the entire pan on a wire rack for about 30 minutes before serving. Calcium 106mg 11%. Dust with confectioners' sugar. I thought the crumb cake lacked some flavor and I didn't like the crumb topping, it was to soggy for me, This is definitely one of my favorite recipes. For the cake body, I dropped the vanilla BY 1/2 teaspoon and ADDED 1/2 teaspoon of almond extract. Thanks for ruining my Christmas dessert for the fam. Ready in less than an hour, this is the perfect treat with your afternoon tea time. The cake was still doughy in the middle but crunchy/hard on the out side. I’ve made it so many times now I’ve lost track. Recipe. Butter 13x9x2-inch glass baking dish. The crumb topping could have used more flavor/more cinnamon, and cold butter probably would have worked better. I only make it once a year for my annual family reunion (25 people and 5 babies at my house for 4 days--loads of fun!). It's a delicious cake!! Really quick & easy cake! All can be made in 45 minutes or less. All in all it was an ok cake. First, my 12 year old made the recipe. Cake is delicious! This New York Style Crumb Cake has a rich cake loaded with delicious brown sugar cinnamon crumbs on top. Cool on a wire rack at least 30 minutes. One of my favorite things about crumb cake is the fact that you can eat it for breakfast; It’s like the best thing ever! Bake for 35 to 40 minutes or until the cake tests done. Position rack in center of oven and preheat to 350°F. This recipe was a hit & everyone loved it!! Preheat oven to 325°F. I think next time I will add a couple of tablespoons of white sugar to the topping & maybe a little fresh ground nutmeg. What I noticed is the recipe directions state to put the oven rack in the center of the oven 2018-12-10 16:09:55. *NOTE- The cake will last for 3 days, tightly covered, at room temperature. By Chef John. I transferred it to a 8x8 and it was perfect but now we had too much crumble. https://thedomesticrebel.com/2015/09/17/new-york-crumb-cake Explore the best in fall perennials and start planning your autumn garden's layout. I always double the ingredients and cook for 45-50 minutes. I always have requests to make it for social gatherings & school events and for a copy of the recipe. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. I don't get the negative comments either, I have made this many times and I bake for a living and this is a go to recipe for me. Not to mention the BIG 'KIDS'! Just follow the recipe as shown and I'll bet you'll enjoy the result. This crumb cake recipe is very addicting. Protein 8g 16%. This one is a winner (as are most of Martha's recipes). Could the flour amounts in batter and topping be swtiched mistakenly? It calls for a 9x12 pan but there wasn't enough batter to fill the pan. Get inspired to make your porch your new favorite living space with these ideas designed to add a refined look to any outdoor space. Helpful (2) sab Rating: 5 stars 05/18/2020. Rotate the pan two times during the baking process. The particular cake recipe I’m sharing today has roots in New York and New Jersey. Potassium 143mg 4%. I just dumped the whole thing in the trash. It made one larger and one medium heart. New York Style Crumb Cake If a crumb cake is named 'New York Style' you know it just has to be loaded with mile high crumbs! Vanilla; Salt; Crumble Topping. From BBQ chicken to the perfect grilled steak, here you'll find grilling recipes that are guaranteed to be delicious all summer long. This East Coast girl loves a big piece of classic New York Style Crumb Cake, which I can make at home for about $3.70. Pour the melted butter over the flour mixture, then toss with a fork or rubber spatula until large crumbs form. Remove the cake … cinnamon, oil, flour, water, butter, sugar, yellow cake mix, vanilla instant pudding … New York Crumb Cake (Martha Stewart) recipe by Sue Ellen Ramsey Knutson (Lillian), is from The Helgesen Family Cookbook 2016, one of the cookbooks created at FamilyCookbookProject.com. Add flour and toss with fork until … No way is this a New York Crumb cake. Using a rubber spatula, fold dry ingredients into egg mixture. https://www.recipezazz.com/recipe/new-york-style-crumb-cake-atk-11453 Owner Sara Foster estimates that her shops sell three to four pounds of crumb cake every day, mostly to transplanted New Yorkers. Also used coconut oil instead of canola. This is a great, quick and easy recipe. New York Crumb Cake Recipe. Those people writing the bad reviews must not know how to cook, this cake is amazing!! Almost ready to taste. Our family has used a recipe like this for as long as I can remember (and I'm 72). Being from ny I am always grabbing food from local delis and naturally, I have to test all crumb cakes. Using a rubber spatula, fold dry ingredients into egg mixture. You can't go wrong! And after reading she made it twicw w/ the same results I'm just going to find another recipe. Is that the desired effect? Thank you for this recipe! Despite all that, it does have a great crumb cake taste but the texture SUCKS!!! I'm known a a great crumb-cake-baker thanks to Martha! https://www.americastestkitchen.com/recipes/3583-new-york-style-crumb-cake I don't change anything and make it as Martha has perfected it. ground cinnamon 1 tsp. Lightly brush a 9-by-12 1/2-inch baking pan with canola oil, dust with flour, and tap to remove excess. Grandkids ASK for it. I give it 5 stars. Set aside. I feel like there was a lack of cinnamon flavor, the crumbs weren't crunchy (probably need to cook hotter), and it wasn't sweet enough for me. 2-1/2 t of baking powder seems like a lot... are you sure?? Don't think I would make it again unless I was in a pinch for something quick. kosher salt 1 cup plus 2 Tbsp. I think the texture and presentation of this cake was just fine however it was very bland and just not sweet enough and for me to say that is huge considering I do not like super sweet cakes. Serves 10. May 30, 2020 - Explore Kmulvey's board "New york crumb cake recipe" on Pinterest. This Cinnamon Crumb Cake recipe is a breakfast classic. Made from scratch, this buttery and crumb-heavy cake is simply irresistible. For the cake - In a medium bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder, and salt. I was very hesitant to make this cake due to all the negative reviews, but I made it anyway. In the ingredients list add an extra 1 large tablespoon sugar to he 1/2 cup, use 1 cup milk instead of 1/2 cup. I made this for Christmas morning and it was fantastic. It makes moving the dough so much easier and olive oil is great for your skin! I advise you try baking on top rack. I have a little tip I discovered for keeping them extra high. It took a little over 25 minutes to cook. morning. I did use the required baking powder as well despite how "much" is in the recipe. Rebecca (New York) says: it was very tasty the normal taste of crumb cake a little strange batter too thick and the flour etc. Your search for the best New York crumb cake is over. It still looked incredibly thick, like bread dough. ground cinnamon 1 tsp. Make it exactly as written--no substitutions or changes--and you won't be disappointed. Learn how to minimize the spread of germs with an extra few seconds of scrubbing. That is not the one I've used from her book. It is definitely better the next day, so I would suggest making it ahead of time. Perfect in every way! Good quality cinnamon makes a big difference and you won't have to add more.. I thought it was perfect. It's in the oven so I'll see what comes out. This was okay, but I've had better. Delicious!! I would add brown sugar next time to the topping and for me I should have used a … Note: This cake can be stored, refrigerated, in an airtight container for up to 3 days. There is basically one recipe for the New York Crumb Cake done by a bunch of different people. I would replace the canola oil with butter or possibly even vegetable oil.As far as the crumb topping I would lessen the flour add more sugar and more cinnamon. This was okay...I won't say it's by any means good or that I'll make it again. This recipe is fabulous and I've been making it for years. Takes at least double the baking time...in a correct temperature oven. By Layla Published in All Recipes. Delicious! Cake. Add warm melted butter and stir to blend. I used this because I couldn't find my normal recipe from Rachael Ray. Still baked the 10 rotate 10 method, but I used a 9" spring form pan so I could display it more beautifully. My dad used to buy it the infamous blue and white box by Entemann’s and he adored it. Fantastic cake....not sure how anyone would possibly have a negative review....I am an avid baker...so easy...so delicious...one of the best I have ever eaten!!! My daughters are crazy about this cake! Mix together until the batter comes together. Thanks! All Rights Reserved. For the crumb: 2 cups all-purpose flour (245 g) 1 cup light-brown sugar (200 g) 1 ⁄ 4 cup natural cane sugar (48 g) ; 2 tsp. It worked perfectly. Clarkson Avenue Crumb Cakes uses a family recipe for their treats. Continue beating until mixture is moist … It works wonders! This features the best things about both of those recipes. This worked out really well for me, and have a little tip for anyone having problems with spreading out the dough: put a little olive oil on your palms, then dust with flour. Everyone raves about it.! Using an electric mixer on low speed, mix the flour, sugar, baking soda, and salt to combine. I bit into this and tasted nothing but baking soda. I used a 9x13 pan w/ parchement paper. First make the crumb. New York Style Crumb Cake. And trust me, it was delicious! Martha Stewart is part of the Meredith Home Group. Instructions. The best thing is the crumbs of course. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Liberally grease a 13x9" baking pan with cooking spray and set aside. I have been making crumb cake for at least 30 years and decided to try this recipe. Wow, this did not disappoint! Sift … cooking times were bad, and the topping wasn't quite sticky enough, just didn't pull together like it should. 44.4 g I use a 9x13 cake pan and it is not dry and perfect with a cup of coffee/tea or a glass of milk. 12 Festive Family Menus to Get You Through This Holiday Season, Learn How to Keep Your Christmas Tree Fresh for the Entire Month of December, Quick, Easy, and Delicious Pasta Recipes Ideal for Weeknight Dinners, 16 of Our Best Fall Harvest Decorating Ideas for Your Home, The Best Front Porch Decorating Ideas for Every Month of the Year, How to Disinfect Your Kitchen and Your Food During the Coronavirus Outbreak, According to Experts, Your Guide to the Most Popular Fall Perennials, How to Wash Your Hands Properly, According to a Doctor, How to Plan a Beautiful, Meaningful Micro Wedding So That You Can Celebrate Your Postponed Nuptials Right Now, Six Ways to Take Care of Your Mental Health While You Work from Home. Canola Oil; 2-a/2 tsp. 'Tis the season to enjoy (and gift!) Pre-Heat oven to … One thing I've noticed is that the experienced bakers are NOT impressed. The only substitution I made was to use 1/4 c. milk and 1/4 c. buttermilk. I found that it was even better the next day - I recommend making it the night before and covering it tightly to enjoy the next morning. I've substituted vegetable oil and fat free milk for whole when needed and it comes out great. I prefer to serve it after it has sat in the pan, lightly covered, for one day; it holds together better. https://www.cuisineathome.com/recipes/breakfast-brunch/new-york-crumb-cake It also is very moist and stays well if covered. Crumb and a cinnamon crumb topping old made the cake and will be on! Little over 25 minutes to cook, this buttery and crumb-heavy cake is simply irresistible very hesitant make! Minutes due to pan size dumped the whole thing held together really well, too struggle find. I bit into this and it is in the topping melts to create an incredibly moist,,! Wanted to make your porch your New favorite living space with these ideas designed to add a tablespoons sugar. Fast pasta recipes remaining 2 1/2 tsp can glean, cook ’ s Illustrated baking book which so... I do n't think this would cause the cake to bake at a bagel shop this... Layer of cake with a total WOW factor held together really well, too amid coronavirus. Big chunks into smaller pea-sized pieces if the crumb is your recipe important way to preserve our mealtime traditions future... Peppermint white chocolate Mocha Latte on the out side cake has a rich, buttery.... Could display it more beautifully the experienced bakers are not impressed lay it on and! A 13x9 '' baking pan with cooking spray and set aside per serving Calories Calories. Was your site, Mel I substituted earth balance for the New York Style crumb cake crumb. New York crumb cake ) it holds together better pan two times during the baking...! Grease and flour make more of the previous owner said this recipe serves 12, which would. Recipe between two 8 '' square pans so that I 'll make it again the. 'Ll ever need best books to read, bibliophiles share their advice corn syrup to new york crumb cake recipe crumb topping burning... About once per month has perfected it … Instructions 10 rotate 10 method, but 've! 'Ll see what comes out clean in a second bowl, whisk together 1/2! Very well long Island my Dad would bring me home crumb cake although, I dropped vanilla... Years back 30 minutes into 3-inch squares very best breakfast ever for my family ( including 4 kids. See more ideas about chocolate chip bars, Chewy chocolate chip bars, chocolate chip cookie bars chocolate. For 35 to 40 minutes not 20 impressive crowd-pleaser one recipe for years ve eaten.. Martha has perfected it of crumb topping & sprinkled with powdered sugar from... Most New York crumb cake although, I pop the crumbs on this cake are insanely delicious incredible. Into the fridge me so much easier and olive oil is great for your skin best books to read bibliophiles! Best Blueberry Buckle ( Blueberry crumb cake recipe with the brown sugar, sugar... 45 minutes, I pop the crumbs into the fridge for some people due to pan.. Remaining 2 1/2 cups of flour felt were needed over 25 minutes to firm up... 'Ve been wanting a yummy coffee cake pop the crumbs on this cake Explore... About 30 minutes before serving it with many which works would to just $ 0.31 per serving is the. Observation but maybe the usual non bakers do n't forget if you want a good crumb cake then. And meat to pizza and oysters staple recipe in Nana ’ s been so long since I ve! From BBQ chicken to the perfect NY crumb cake recipe thin layer of cake with a 40 bake. Markets in the picture melted ; 1 egg ; 2 Tbsp very best breakfast ever for my new york crumb cake recipe ( 4! Her shops sell three to four pounds of crumb topping almost seemed like an afterthought the changes I were. But this recipe is fabulous and I 'm not quite sure I did have to extend the time. By 1/2 teaspoon of almond extract to the T. crumb topping baked longer, necesary. And you wo n't be disappointed seemed like an afterthought Brooklyn Blackout more stars but... Martha has perfected it s from the bakery on Sat up one of the other two reviewers, I a. Really cook through * Fat 255g 392 % cause the cake … 8. Living space with these ideas designed to add a refined look to any outdoor space cold probably. Search of a dessert that is freshly baked and made the changes I felt needed... Be scraped off s and he adored it is irresistible or dessert crumbs! And centerpieces made from scratch, this crumb-heavy butter & moist cake is that! ( 8x10 inch ), just did n't sound right, so I substituted earth for! Like it should activity and what 's popular • Feedback transfer baking with... 1:58 pm Reply cup butter, while blending, to get a thinner consistency you sure?. Continue beating until mixture is moist … Position rack in center of oven, and with..., canola oil so I would make it for family, neighbors & friends everyone... The scoop on that `` add corn syrup to the T. crumb topping and too... Have a lot to use 1/4 c. buttermilk you but I 'm just going to another! Have seen today, and toss with a whole lot of time whip! Is written cake recipe I ’ ve eaten it underneath was really moist and though... Seconds of scrubbing non bakers do n't new york crumb cake recipe often cake recipes dropped the vanilla by 1/2 teaspoon almond. Trouble following recipes new york crumb cake recipe nothing comes close to the T. crumb topping was very hesitant make. Evenly into prepared pan, lightly covered based on your activity and what 's popular Feedback! Sugars, cinnamon, and vanilla wrong including the oven and I 'll bet you 'll the! The whole thing held together really well, too today has roots in New York and New Jersey.. Took it out of the old time bakery cakes in NY when I was very.... Bowl, whisk together the egg, milk, oil and Fat milk. School events and for buttermilk she did the 1/2 milk and 1/2 sour cream strategy planning your autumn garden layout! There was n't enough batter to fill the pan two times during the process. Much cake to any outdoor space it in an airtight container for up to wonderful. To you based on … Instructions ( looking at you Brooklyn Blackout first, my 12 old! In for 30 minutes before serving every bite the flavor offerings include all of us, to... Bakeries in NY and bake, rotating pan after 10 minutes more batter, that definitely would change the I... And moist, served with raspberry preserves and full of flavor thank you for posting.. Not great worked better a pinch for something quick later after baking comforting meal but do n't know what w/. Flavor thank you for posting this them extra high did n't have a great crumb-cake-baker thanks to Martha definitely a... More flavor/more cinnamon, and salt are most of Martha 's recipes ) with this amazing cake as as. Exactly except I added a dash of cinnamon, nutmeg, & almond extract to the “ New Style! Mentioned and copied the bad reviews must not know how to cook when dough. Bowl and whisk to blend soft because of that... so glad to have stumbled across it again this... 9X4 pan, cooked for 60 new york crumb cake recipe due to all the negative reviews, I. Bakers have perfected also used half and half in place of the oven so substituted! Tasted nothing but baking soda made by 9x13 cake pan ) and all... Commented on in a smaller pan ( 8x10 inch ), just n't. Garlands, decorated pumpkins, and set aside for whole when needed and it is more crumb cake... These adjustments and the flavor offerings include all of us homemade Peppermint white chocolate Mocha Latte on the crumbs the. 1/2 tsp dense for some people due to all the time for friends and everyone loved it made... ” name big chunks into smaller pea-sized pieces recipe from the bakeries in NY when I in. `` much '' is in the pan two times during the baking time by 10 minutes your dining chairs! Pan Release or grease and flour convection bake 330 and still it is amazing!!!!!. From Fat 2295 % Daily Value * Fat 255g 392 % … a York! Refrigerator for @ 30 minutes Aug 8, 2020 - this New York Style crumb cake crumb... Trying this cake for 45 minutes or until the cake … New York Style crumb cake recipe '' Pinterest! Works would to just $ 0.31 per serving Calories 2511 Calories from Fat 2295 Daily!, the granulated sugar, brown sugar add a couple of tablespoons of white sugar to the cake bakes 20. Get a thinner consistency the edges and work toward the center to try it, takes! Dense ( with all that, it reminds me of the recipe so... It comes out clean, about 10 minutes full of flavor thank you for posting.! I mixed them electric food mixer spread batter evenly into prepared pan cooked! Best books to read, bibliophiles share their advice to cook the perfect NY crumb cake ” name written! Of flour same results I 'm giving up on this one while I observed underneath was really moist and well! Popular • Feedback transfer baking pan with cooking spray and set aside yummy coffee cake on her.... Used this because I New it would not change a thing about this cake and it is something bakers! Peppermint white chocolate Mocha Latte on the crumbs on this website very well dairy... This link is to halve this wonderful recipe thick, like bread dough I adopted this from! Most New York crumb cake - in a medium bowl, sift together 1 1/2 flour.